I love the Scarpas I bought. One of my feet is about half a size bigger than the other, so I went for a bigger size than I'd normally wear. I ended up walking through the swamp at Myola, rather than around the edge - misjudged and ended up ankle deep in mud.

My boots were totally gross, but my socks/feet stayed dry, so I was pretty impressed by that. My carrier washed my boots in the river and put them in a drying hut for the night and they were almost totally dry the next morning. The only time my feet got completely wet was the last day and a half, with the river crossings, but I landed on my butt in the water and didn't care by then. I do have to say that after cleaning them properly when I got back to the hotel, it took a few days to get them fully dry again.
My dad, on the other hand, wore leather boots, and he loved those and didn't think mine would do the job.
I spent about 90 minutes bugging the guy at Paddy Pallin about all the different types of shoes and trying them on, before I settled on the ones I bought. I have small feet so could not give them to my carrier or any of the other boys, but those boots will definitely be going back with me next year. Cost a fair bit, but well worth the time spent finding the right ones.